The Vancouver Canucks are currently grappling with inconsistent performances, a stark contrast to their dominant 2023-24 season where they clinched the Pacific Division title and reached Game 7 of the Western Conference Semi-Finals. This season, they find themselves just one point away from fifth place in the division, with internal challenges further complicating their journey.
A significant internal issue has been the reported discord between star forwards J.T. Miller and Elias Pettersson. In response, General Manager Patrik Allvin traded Miller to the New York Rangers, despite public denials of any rift from both players. Currently, Pettersson remains under contract with the Canucks for several more years. However, discussions are emerging about the possibility of moving him before his no-trade clause becomes active.
This season, Pettersson’s performance has been underwhelming, especially considering his eight-year, $92.8 million contract (averaging $11.6 million annually). He has managed only 11 goals and 24 assists, projecting to a mere 49 points over 74 games—a career low for him in a full 82-game season.
Former NHL general manager and current analyst Craig Button criticized Pettersson’s lackluster performance during a recent appearance on the Donnie & Dhali show. Button highlighted Pettersson’s tentative play and failure to make a significant impact, stating that such performance is unacceptable for a player with an $11.6 million salary. He suggested that head coach Rick Tocchet might be handling Pettersson too gently, potentially hindering the team’s progress.
The question now is whether the Canucks should consider trading Pettersson, especially before his no-trade clause takes effect.
Reasons Against Trading Elias Pettersson
Currently, Pettersson’s trade value is at a career low due to his decreased production. However, he has previously demonstrated his high potential. Just two years ago, he achieved a 102-point season with 39 goals and 63 assists. The following season, he recorded 34 goals and 55 assists, totaling 89 points—still impressive numbers.
Unless General Manager Patrik Allvin and team president Jim Rutherford decide to initiate a complete rebuild, Pettersson should remain a central figure around whom the team can build. His proven capabilities suggest that, with the right support and environment, he can return to being a top performer, aiding the Canucks in reclaiming their status among the NHL’s elite.
Additional Considerations
Recent reports have surfaced regarding Pettersson’s strained relationship with Canucks legends and current assistant coaches, Henrik and Daniel Sedin. This tension adds another layer of complexity to his situation with the team. Despite these challenges, Pettersson has expressed a desire to remain in Vancouver. However, his recent lackluster performances and a minor injury during the Four Nations tournament have sparked discussions about whether he might benefit from a fresh start elsewhere.
Trade rumors have linked Pettersson to teams like the Detroit Red Wings, especially after their recent trade of goaltender Ville Husso to the Anaheim Ducks. Speculation suggests that the Red Wings might be targeting centers like Dylan Cozens or Elias Pettersson to bolster their lineup.
In conclusion, while Pettersson’s current season has been disappointing, his past performances indicate a high ceiling. The Canucks must carefully weigh the potential benefits of retaining him against the risks of a trade, considering both his individual contributions and the team’s overall dynamics.
