The Broncos urgently need to launch a thorough investigation into their dramatic decline in 2024 and should approach it without any attempts to gloss over the situation.
This is a team that was expected to dominate last year’s grand final and boasts one of the strongest rosters in the NRL. However, after suffering a humiliating 40-6 defeat to the Dolphins on Saturday night, they are now on the brink of missing out on the finals entirely this season. In what was a crucial match, the Broncos appeared disinterested, and were thoroughly outplayed by the newcomers to the league.
Given the Broncos’ roster, which includes a wealth of Origin and Test players, and their substantial organizational and fan support, their failure to secure a finals spot is inexcusable. Coach Kevin Walters and his coaching staff need to be scrutinized, as well as several high-paid players who have consistently underperformed.
The review should determine if management needs to make tough decisions, including removing underperforming players and recruiting new, motivated talent to revive the team’s pride and performance in 2025.
In contrast, Newcastle’s star duo, Kalyn Ponga and Bradman Best, showcased their readiness for next weekend’s pivotal match against the Dolphins with an impressive 36-14 victory over the Titans. Both players excelled, with Ponga scoring twice in the first half and Best making significant contributions with over 200 meters run and two try assists. Despite Wayne Bennett’s likely tactical adjustments to counter these threats, Ponga and Best will be crucial to Newcastle’s success.
In another highlight, Shaun Johnson concluded his career on a high note with a memorable performance for the Warriors. Facing Cronulla, his former team, Johnson led the Warriors to a dramatic comeback win. Renowned for his role in popularizing rugby league in New Zealand, Johnson received a haka from Kiwi players from both teams as a tribute to his career before leaving the field with a smile.
Meanwhile, Herbie Farnworth delivered an outstanding performance in the Broncos game against the Dolphins. His two tries, two assists, and nearly 300 meters run demonstrated his exceptional skills. Farnworth, having made a significant impact since joining the Dolphins, is poised to be a major threat in the finals if his team can advance past Newcastle.
Clint Gutherson, a stalwart of the Eels, showed his enduring quality in their 44-40 victory over the Dragons. Despite his preference for playing as a fullback, Gutherson’s two tries, assist, and 200 meters run highlighted his ongoing value to the team, presenting a strong case to new coach Jason Ryles regarding his role in the upcoming season.
In a poignant moment, Tyrone Munro of the Rabbitohs, despite the recent loss of his mother and uncle, chose to play against Penrith. His decision to participate and score both of Souths’ tries amidst personal tragedy demonstrated his resilience and commitment. Munro’s performance underscored his potential and determination to succeed in the sport.
On the other hand, Stephen Crichton’s absence was clearly felt as the Bulldogs suffered a 34-22 defeat to Manly. Crichton’s defensive and attacking contributions were sorely missed, with the team showing vulnerabilities that they had not previously exposed. For the Bulldogs to advance in the finals, they urgently need Crichton back on the field.
Lastly, the Cowboys’ 38-30 victory over the Storm was marked by a lackluster performance despite their win. The Storm, missing key players and fielding a weakened side, still managed to expose the Cowboys’ deficiencies. Coach Todd Payten will likely address the team’s poor attitude and defensive lapses, as these issues could lead to early elimination in the finals if not corrected.
