The Round 23 Report Card for the 2024 AFL season reveals a dramatic weekend with six teams receiving A-plus grades while four others faced failures. With only nine games left to finalize the top eight, teams experienced ups and downs, with notable performances shaping the finals race.
Adelaide Crows
faced a tough challenge in the Showdown, managing to stay competitive for three quarters but faltering in the final term as they allowed Port Adelaide to surge ahead. Despite a positive clearance battle, Adelaide struggled with efficiency, finishing with a C+ grade. Key players included Jordan Dawson with 26 disposals and Max Michalanney with 16 disposals, but the team lacked effectiveness inside 50.
Brisbane Lions
relinquished a commanding position against Collingwood, losing in a second-half collapse. Their inability to maintain pressure was highlighted by a concerning tackling differential. Hugh McCluggage and Josh Dunkley were standouts, but the team’s performance led to a C- grade, reflecting their failure to secure a top-four finish as they face a must-win game against Essendon.
Carlton
displayed impressive form, with their young players stepping up in a decisive win over West Coast. The Blues dominated key statistical areas, including disposals and inside-50s, leading to an A+ grade. Patrick Cripps and George Hewett were pivotal, ensuring Carlton’s strong position heading into their crucial final-round match.
Collingwood
staged a remarkable comeback to defeat Brisbane, overcoming a challenging first half with relentless pressure. Their tackling and resilience were exceptional, earning them an A+ grade. Nick Daicos shone with a standout performance, but the team still faces an uphill battle to secure a finals berth.
Essendon
saw their finals hopes dim after a narrow loss to Sydney. Despite dominating the first half, they were unable to capitalize on opportunities, leading to a C- grade. Dylan Shiel and Nic Martin were key performers, but finishing issues cost the Bombers dearly.
Fremantle
fought hard against GWS but fell short, highlighting their struggle to overcome deficits. Key players like Andrew Brayshaw and Caleb Serong contributed significantly, but the team’s inability to close games led to a C grade. Their final-round fixture against Port Adelaide may not affect the finals if other results don’t go their way.
Geelong
experienced a shocking turnaround, surrendering a large lead to St Kilda. The Cats’ lack of contest-related stats and a significant drop in performance during the second half resulted in a disappointing D grade. Patrick Dangerfield and Jeremy Cameron were notable performers but could not prevent the loss.
Gold Coast Suns
continued their disappointing season with a lackluster performance against Melbourne. Despite individual efforts from Noah Anderson and Touk Miller, the Suns’ forward line struggled, and their performance was graded F due to ineffective play.
GWS Giants
secured their double chance with a win over Fremantle, marking them as strong contenders for the premiership. Brent Daniels and Jesse Hogan were instrumental in the victory, leading to an A grade for their comprehensive performance.
Hawthorn
delivered a dominant display against Richmond, with significant advantages in disposals and tackles. Jai Newcombe and James Worpel were standout players, and despite minor injury concerns, the Hawks’ performance earned them an A+ grade as they aim to secure a top-four finish.
Melbourne
bounced back from off-field issues to decisively defeat Gold Coast. Jack Viney and Ed Langdon led a strong team performance, resulting in an A+ grade. The win was a positive note for a season that has had its share of disappointments.
North Melbourne
struggled against Western Bulldogs, with key defenders being a major issue. Despite some solid individual performances, the team’s overall performance resulted in an F grade, reflecting a challenging season.
Port Adelaide
clinched a top-four finish with a commanding win over Adelaide, dominating in the midfield. Zak Butters and Connor Rozee were standout performers, contributing to an A grade. However, the potential suspension of Dan Houston poses a future challenge for the team.
Richmond
had a dismal performance against Hawthorn, with significant deficiencies across all statistical categories. Despite some individual efforts, the Tigers’ performance was marked with an F grade, emphasizing the need for substantial improvement.
St Kilda
executed a stunning comeback to defeat Geelong, with impressive performances from Cal Wilkie and Rowan Marshall. Their turnaround earned them an A+ grade, showcasing their potential as they head into the final round.
Sydney Swans
secured the minor premiership with a dominant second half against Essendon. Isaac Heeney and Luke Parker played pivotal roles, leading to an A- grade. However, improving their first-quarter performance remains a focus.
West Coast Eagles
were disappointing in their loss to Carlton, failing to contain the Blues’ midfield dominance. Despite efforts from Elliot Yeo and Harley Reid, their performance was graded F, putting pressure on coach Jarrad Schofield’s future.
Western Bulldogs
had a comprehensive win over North Melbourne, with standout performances from Sam Darcy and other young players. Their effective play and dominance in key areas resulted in a high grading, setting them up well for the finals.
The report card reflects the high stakes and intense competition as teams approach the final round of the season.
