Ross Atkins Sparks Controversy: Blue Jays DFA Top Prospect Hagen Danner for Questionable Signing
Toronto Blue Jays General Manager Ross Atkins has drawn scrutiny after a puzzling roster move this offseason. To make space for newly signed pitcher Josh Walker, Atkins opted to designate highly regarded pitching prospect Hagen Danner for assignment (DFA), a decision that left many fans and analysts baffled.
A Move That Raises Eyebrows
The Blue Jays announced the signing of left-handed pitcher Josh Walker to a one-year, $760,000 contract, marking their second major league signing of the offseason. However, the move required the team to clear a roster spot, which led to Danner being placed on waivers. Given Danner’s promising stats and potential, many are questioning whether this decision was shortsighted.
Danner, who spent last season in Triple-A, posted solid numbers despite battling injuries. Over 34.1 innings pitched, he registered a respectable 3.15 ERA, struck out 34 batters, and recorded seven saves. These statistics highlighted his potential as a future contributor to the Blue Jays’ bullpen.
In contrast, Josh Walker’s recent performance has been less than stellar. The 28-year-old lefty began the 2024 season with the Mets’ affiliate, where he posted a solid 2.83 ERA. However, after being released and picked up by the Pittsburgh Pirates, his performance declined sharply, finishing the season with an 8.00 ERA over just nine innings. Overall, Walker ended the year with a 4.06 ERA—a significant downgrade compared to Danner’s numbers.
Why Take the Risk?
The decision to DFA Danner is particularly perplexing because it opens the door for other teams to claim him off waivers. As a top pitching prospect, Danner is likely to draw interest from rival teams, making it a gamble that could come back to haunt the Blue Jays.
On the surface, it seems Atkins was willing to part ways with a young talent to bring in a player who, by most accounts, might not even have secured a major league deal with another team. Walker’s inconsistent performance and limited upside make the move all the more controversial.
Offseason Questions Mount
This decision is part of a larger pattern of offseason moves that have left Blue Jays fans scratching their heads. Earlier, the team acquired second baseman Andrés Giménez, a defensive specialist who offers little offensive firepower—something the team desperately needs. Coupled with the Danner decision, many are questioning whether Atkins has a clear strategy in place.
The Blue Jays are coming off a season where bullpen depth and offensive consistency were glaring issues. While bolstering the roster is critical, moves like signing Walker at the expense of a promising prospect like Danner seem counterproductive.
Fan Reaction and Implications
The reaction from fans has been swift and critical. Many view the decision as a misstep that prioritizes short-term roster flexibility over long-term development. Losing a talent like Danner could sting, especially if he goes on to thrive with another team.
Atkins’ gamble also raises questions about the Blue Jays’ approach to player development and talent evaluation. Are they undervaluing homegrown prospects in favor of fringe major league additions?
As the offseason continues, the spotlight remains on Atkins to justify his moves and demonstrate a coherent plan for the Blue Jays’ future. For now, the decision to DFA Hagen Danner has cast doubt on the team’s strategy and left fans wondering if this gamble was worth the potential cost.
