In a surprising article released on Friday, Seth Walder, an ESPN sports analytics writer, proposed an unexpected idea that the Cleveland Browns should consider trading for quarterback Justin Fields from the Chicago Bears. This move, according to Walder, would mark the start of a transition away from Deshaun Watson as the Browns’ primary quarterback.
Walder acknowledged the unconventional nature of his suggestion in the article, stating, “I understand this is quite an unconventional idea.” He proposed that the Browns should reevaluate their situation with Deshaun Watson, considering the significant financial commitment and lack of a first-round pick. Instead, he recommended pursuing an upgrade at quarterback by trading a second- or third-round pick for Justin Fields, who is still on his rookie contract. Walder expressed curiosity about seeing Fields thrive in Kevin Stefanski’s offensive system.
There are several factors to consider in this situation. Firstly, it is important to acknowledge the allegations of sexual misconduct that have surrounded Deshaun Watson for years. Leaving aside personal opinions on these allegations, Browns general manager Andrew Berry recently defended the decision to acquire Watson through a controversial trade with the Houston Texans. Given the substantial financial commitment and the fact that Watson signed a fully guaranteed five-year, $230 million contract in March 2022, it is unlikely that the Browns would relegate him to a backup role in order to start an unproven player like Justin Fields.
Furthermore, various sources, including ESPN and CBS, have speculated that the Chicago Bears may select USC Trojans quarterback Caleb Williams with the first overall pick in this year’s draft. This speculation is partly due to Justin Fields’ failure to establish himself as a long-term NFL starter over the past three seasons. Additionally, quarterback-needy teams like the Atlanta Falcons and Pittsburgh Steelers have been linked to Fields and could potentially outbid the Browns in a trade for his services.
Neither Andrew Berry nor head coach Kevin Stefanski have indicated any intention to move on from Deshaun Watson. While Watson has played in fewer than 12 full games with the Browns over the past two seasons, it is more likely that Berry will rely on new offensive coordinator Ken Dorsey to help Watson regain his previous form, considering his status as a three-time Pro Bowl selection with the Houston Texans. This assumes that Watson will provide the Browns with more than just a few starts in the upcoming season.
