Former NFL players JJ Watt and Pat McAfee, along with Miami Dolphins safety Jevon Holland, have criticized the NFL’s decision to ban the hip-drop tackle. The league made the decision during the owners’ meetings and plans to fine players who break the new rule next season. The hip-drop tackle, where a defensive player falls onto the attacker’s legs, has been deemed to pose a significantly higher risk of injury, according to NFL executive Jeff Miller. However, many former and current players disagree with the decision. McAfee expressed his disagreement on social media, stating that some of the banned tackles are considered normal tackles in most football circles. Watt suggested that the NFL is moving towards a flag football style of play. Other players, including Ryan Clark and Jevon Holland, also criticized the decision, expressing concerns that the game is becoming too focused on flag football. Former quarterback Robert Griffin III commented that the ban on the hip-drop tackle is a step towards turning football into physical flag football.
In a video clip, former quarterback Robert Griffin III acknowledged that the NFL has unanimously voted to ban the hip-drop tackle. He mentioned that he understands the league’s intention to protect players and make the game safer, considering the inherent risks involved in football. However, he also highlighted the challenging nature of creating a safe environment in a sport that inherently carries risks.
In response to the NFL’s decision to ban the hip-drop tackle, there are concerns raised by players and team owners. Some express sympathy for defenders, as they feel the rules are increasingly limiting their ability to play defense effectively. Dallas Cowboys owner Jerry Jones had previously anticipated the ban, and according to NFL Network reporter Ian Rapoport, the tackle has now been officially prohibited. Breaking the new rule will result in fines for players, and a 15-yard penalty plus a first down will be enforced if the technique is used. Rich McKay, chairman of the NFL’s competition committee, described the hip-drop tackle as a method where the defender encircles the runner and then swings their weight, falling on the side of the runner’s leg, potentially causing injury to the ankle or knee.
Indeed, the use of the hip-drop tackle tactic can be seen as a strategy employed by smaller defenders against larger opponents to bring them down effectively, which aligns with the objective of the game. However, a concern arises when the runner becomes defenseless as a result of this tackle. The weight of the defender falling on the side of the runner’s leg can trap the ankle, causing potential injury. This highlights the delicate balance between effective defensive play and the need to prioritize player safety in the NFL.
